Side Characters That Deserve Better: Breaking Free from Character Clichés

Let’s face it: side characters often get the short end of the narrative stick. They are there to support the hero, lighten the mood, or fill in the blanks between major plot points. But what if we expect more from them? What if, instead of flat, predictable characters, these secondary roles became as dynamic and compelling as the protagonist?

We’ve all seen these tropes before: the wise mentor, comic relief, token best friend. They’re familiar and comforting, but they’re also stale if left unchallenged. So, how do you breathe life into these side characters without letting them fall into the trap of the cliché? Let’s explore how to break these molds and build side characters that feel just as important as the main cast.

1. Wise Mentor

Cliché: We all know this one—the older, wise figure who guides the hero, offers sage advice, and then either dies or conveniently steps aside so the protagonist can take center stage. Think of Gandalf from The Lord of the Rings or Dumbledore from the Harry Potter series.

Subversion: Why not give the mentor some serious flaws? What if their advice isn’t always right? Perhaps they have a hidden agenda, or they’re morally ambiguous and lead the protagonist into more trouble than they expected. A mentor who isn't infallible forces the hero to think for themselves, to question their guidance, and to grow not because of the mentor, but despite them.

2. Comic Relief

Cliché: This character's only function is to crack jokes, usually at inappropriate moments. Think Jar Jar Binks from Star Wars. They exist solely to lighten the mood but often come across as flat and disconnected from the emotional depth of the story.

Subversion: Humor is a mask. What if the comic relief character is using humor to hide trauma, insecurity, or fear? Maybe their jokes deflect attention from their own pain. And what if they have a moment of real vulnerability or significance that changes the course of the story? By giving them emotional depth, you transform them from a punchline into a person.

3. Token Best Friend

Cliché: This character is the loyal, always-there friend who has no ambitions or arc of their own. Think Ron Weasley in the early books of the Harry Potter series, who is mostly there to support Harry’s journey. These characters cheer for the protagonist, but that’s where their stories begin and end.

Subversion: Let your best friend character have their own dreams, conflicts, and even moments when they outshine the protagonist. What if their goals clash with the protagonist’s? What if they aren’t willing to stick around and be the sidekick forever? Tension between the protagonist and the best friend can create rich layers of conflict.

4. Love Interest

Cliché: The love interest is often little more than a prize to be won, existing to motivate or distract the hero. Mary Jane in the early Spider-Man films fits this mold, as do countless other love interests in blockbuster movies.

Subversion: Make the love interest an independent, fully realized character. They have their own goals, their own struggles, and maybe their story doesn’t revolve around the protagonist at all. Maybe they’re not interested in romance with the protagonist, or perhaps they become a mentor or an antagonist. Romance doesn’t have to be their defining trait.

5. Villain’s Henchman

Cliché: This character is a faceless, nameless goon who does the villain’s dirty work without question, often just to be defeated by the hero. Their sole purpose is to be an obstacle to the hero.

Subversion: What if the henchman has their own backstory, their own motives? Maybe they’re more capable than the villain themselves or secretly plotting to overthrow their boss. Or perhaps they’re a sympathetic character, trapped in a bad situation and making the best of it. When your henchman has stakes in the story, they become more than just cannon fodder.

6. Damsel in Distress

Cliché: This character, typically a woman, has only one purpose: to be saved by the hero. They are defined by their helplessness, waiting for rescue—think Princess Peach in early Mario games.

Subversion: What if the damsel in distress saves themselves? Or even better, what if they’re the one who rescues the protagonist? A character who actively fights to change their own fate becomes a powerful, dynamic force in the story. They no longer exist to be saved, but to shape the narrative in their own right.

7. Dead Parent Backstory

Cliché: The dead parent backstory is an overused trope often used to explain why a character is tough, motivated, or emotionally distant. But this can quickly become a one-note device if it's the sole defining feature of a character.

Subversion: Rather than focusing on dead parents as a character’s entire motivation, explore complex family dynamics. Maybe the character has unresolved conflicts with a living parent, or their relationship with the deceased parent was far from perfect. This creates richer emotional territory to explore.

8. All-Knowing Villain’s Sidekick

Cliché: This character is the stoic second-in-command who carries out the villain’s plans with cold efficiency. They lack their own motivations and serve solely to support the antagonist.

Subversion: What if the sidekick secretly opposes the villain’s goals? Maybe they’re staying out of fear, loyalty, or self-interest. Perhaps they are the brains behind the operation and eventually grow tired of being overshadowed. A sidekick with internal conflict can become a wildcard, adding unexpected layers to the narrative as the villain’s plans come into play.

Side characters don’t have to be flat stereotypes. By subverting these clichés, you can transform them into multidimensional players with their own arcs, stakes, and complexities. A story is so much richer when every character feels like they could be the protagonist of their own tale.

Let’s move beyond the clichés and give side characters the spotlight they deserve.

https://unsplash.com/@jmvillejo